The Substance is a thought-provoking film that blends elements of psychological horror, science fiction, and drama. One of the most gripping aspects of the film is the character of Sue, whose transformation into a monster is both terrifying and tragic. Her metamorphosis is central to the plot, offering layers of meaning and interpretation. But why exactly did Sue turn into a monster? Was it the result of external forces, or was it something deeper rooted in her psyche? In this article, we’ll break down the reasons behind Sue’s transformation, looking at both the narrative and thematic elements that drive her change.
1. The Influence of the Substance
At the heart of the film lies the mysterious Substance, an otherworldly material that has the power to warp reality and alter human biology.
From the outset, it is clear that this Substance has a profound effect on anyone who comes into contact with it. Sue’s exposure to it plays a pivotal role in her descent into monstrousness.
The Substance, as depicted in the film, seems to have a corruptive influence. While it offers remarkable abilities, it also comes with a heavy cost. It is never fully explained, which adds to its ominous nature, but the Substance seems to be a catalyst for the darker, more primal aspects of human nature. For Sue, this exposure triggered the first stage of her transformation.
2. Psychological Breakdown and Trauma
Sue’s past is littered with emotional scars that make her particularly vulnerable to the effects of the Substance. She has a history of trauma, including a difficult childhood and strained relationships. As the film unfolds, we learn that Sue’s psyche is fragile, making her an easy target for the Substance’s destabilizing effects.
The trauma Sue experienced earlier in her life serves as a foundation for her eventual transformation. This background helps explain why she responds so intensely to the Substance’s influence. Her internal demons — feelings of abandonment, anger, and fear — are brought to the surface, making her more susceptible to the mutating powers of the Substance.
3. Physical Mutations as a Manifestation of Inner Conflict
The monstrous form Sue takes on is not just a physical transformation, but a manifestation of her inner turmoil. As her body changes, her mind also begins to warp. This duality is key to understanding why she becomes a monster.
The grotesque appearance Sue adopts is symbolic of her internal conflicts. The more she grapples with her own feelings of inadequacy, rage, and confusion, the more her physical form distorts. The film uses her monstrous appearance to highlight how the Substance not only manipulates the body but also exacerbates the flaws and unresolved conflicts of the mind.
Her external monstrosity is the reflection of her internal breakdown, making it clear that her transformation is not just about the power of the Substance, but about how it feeds off her pre-existing vulnerabilities.
4. The Loss of Control
One of the most tragic elements of Sue’s transformation is her loss of control. In the beginning, she shows signs of strength and resistance to the Substance, but as the plot progresses, she becomes overwhelmed by it. This loss of agency is crucial to understanding why she turns into a monster.
In the film, the idea of control is central. Sue starts as a relatively normal person, but as the Substance takes hold, she loses the ability to control her actions and reactions. This loss of self-control — both emotionally and physically — is a key factor in her monstrous transformation. As she becomes more unpredictable and dangerous, she mirrors the complete breakdown of her sense of self.
5. The Allegory of Corruption
Sue’s transformation can also be seen as an allegory for corruption, both personal and societal. The Substance represents external pressures that seek to alter an individual’s nature, and Sue’s mutation illustrates the consequences of succumbing to these forces.
At its core, the film is about the dangers of unchecked power and how easily a person can become consumed by it. Sue is a microcosm of society’s broader struggles with power and corruption. Her turn into a monster is symbolic of how power, unchecked trauma, and vulnerability can corrupt even the most well-meaning individuals. In this sense, Sue’s journey is both personal and societal, a warning about the dangers of losing control to external forces.
6. Sue’s Relationship with Other Characters
Sue’s interactions with other characters also play a role in her transformation. As her relationships with those around her deteriorate, her sense of isolation deepens. This loneliness accelerates her descent into monstrosity.
One key relationship that impacts Sue’s journey is her connection with the film’s protagonist (or perhaps antagonist, depending on perspective). The breakdown of this relationship highlights how Sue’s transformation is not just physical but emotional as well. Her inability to connect with others, coupled with her growing detachment from reality, serves as a catalyst for her monstrous behavior.
Her transformation into a monster is not just a reaction to the Substance, but a result of how she feels misunderstood, abandoned, and betrayed by those closest to her. This emotional devastation plays a crucial role in her loss of humanity, which is depicted visually as her body mutates and becomes more monstrous.
7. The Film’s Use of Horror to Explore Identity
The Substance uses horror as a tool to explore deeper themes of identity and self-perception. Sue’s transformation is symbolic of a larger existential struggle — the fear of losing oneself. Her gradual shift from human to monster reflects the terror of no longer recognizing yourself, which is a theme that resonates throughout the film.
The monstrous form that Sue assumes is not just a physical horror, but a psychological one. As she becomes more monstrous, she loses the sense of who she once was. This loss of identity, paired with her growing alienation, amplifies the horror. The audience is forced to confront the uncomfortable idea that our inner selves — our fears, regrets, and weaknesses — are just as capable of turning us into monsters as any external force.
8. The Ethical Dilemma: Is Sue Truly a Monster?
Finally, it’s important to consider whether Sue’s transformation into a monster is truly her fault. While the Substance plays a significant role in her physical change, Sue’s psychological state is a huge factor. The film raises the question: Is Sue a victim of circumstance, or is she responsible for her monstrous form?
The ethical dilemma is at the heart of Sue’s transformation. The film leaves the question open-ended, allowing the audience to reflect on the nature of monstrosity. Is Sue a victim of forces beyond her control, or did her own actions, choices, and inner darkness lead to her downfall?
In many ways, the film challenges the viewer to reconsider what it means to be a monster. Is it the external appearance that defines monstrosity, or is it the loss of humanity — the breakdown of personal integrity and self-control?
Conclusion
Sue’s transformation into a monster in The Substance is the result of a complex interplay between the external influence of the Substance, her personal trauma, and her internal psychological conflicts. The film uses her character to explore deep themes of identity, control, and corruption, making her transformation both a physical and emotional journey. In the end, Sue’s monstrous form is not just a product of the Substance, but of her own inner struggles and the loss of her humanity. Her transformation serves as a chilling reminder of the dangers of losing control over one’s mind, body, and identity, as well as the devastating impact of unaddressed trauma.
Related topics:
