The world of superhero films has been dominated by two major comic book publishers: Marvel and DC. Among the countless characters that have made it to the big screen, Superman and Black Adam are two iconic figures from the DC universe that have captivated audiences worldwide. Both characters come with their own unique abilities, compelling stories, and larger-than-life personalities. In recent years, their respective films, Man of Steel (2013) and Black Adam (2022), have sparked debates among fans, leaving many to wonder: which one is better?
In this article, we will compare these two films, looking at their themes, characters, storytelling, direction, visual effects, and overall impact on the superhero genre. Through this analysis, we aim to determine which film stands out as the superior experience, or if both films are worthy in their own right.
A Brief Overview of the Films
Man of Steel (2013)
Directed by Zack Snyder and starring Henry Cavill as Superman, Man of Steel was a reboot of the Superman franchise. It explored the origin story of Clark Kent (Superman) as he discovers his powers and comes to terms with his identity as the last son of Krypton. The film delves into the struggles of growing up in a small town while grappling with the responsibility of being an alien in a foreign world. It sets the stage for the DCEU (DC Extended Universe) and features an epic showdown between Superman and General Zod, the villain from Krypton.
Black Adam (2022)
Black Adam, directed by Jaume Collet-Serra, stars Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson as the titular character. Black Adam, a powerful anti-hero from ancient Kahndaq, is awakened in modern times and must confront a group of heroes known as the Justice Society of America (JSA). The film explores themes of power, vengeance, and justice, as Black Adam struggles with his own moral compass and the consequences of his actions. It introduces a new set of characters to the DCEU and provides a darker, more aggressive take on the traditional superhero archetype.
Characters: The Heart of the Films
Superman in Man of Steel
Superman, portrayed by Henry Cavill, is undoubtedly one of the most famous superheroes in comic book history. In Man of Steel, his portrayal is more grounded and serious compared to previous versions of the character. Rather than focusing on the bright and cheery aspects of Superman, the film highlights the internal conflict of Clark Kent as he grapples with his origins, his identity, and his place in the world. This version of Superman is burdened by the weight of his powers and the responsibilities they bring.
His relationship with his Earthly parents, Jonathan and Martha Kent, is a key emotional core of the movie. The guidance from his father Jonathan, who teaches him the value of humility and kindness, contrasts with the stern message from his Kryptonian father Jor-El, who encourages him to embrace his role as Earth’s protector. The duality between these influences adds depth to Superman’s character and sets him on a path of self-discovery.
Black Adam in Black Adam
Black Adam, as portrayed by Dwayne Johnson, is a stark contrast to Superman in many ways. While Superman represents hope, justice, and sacrifice, Black Adam embodies vengeance, raw power, and rebellion. His backstory is that of a man who was once a hero, only to be betrayed and resurrected as a force of destruction. Black Adam’s motivations are rooted in revenge, and his methods of dispensing justice are brutal and unrelenting.
What makes Black Adam stand out as a character is his complex morality. He is not a traditional hero; instead, he operates in a gray area, making him an anti-hero rather than a straight-up villain. His lack of empathy for human life, especially when it comes to those who oppose him, creates an interesting dynamic between him and the other characters in the film, particularly the Justice Society of America (JSA).
Comparing the Characters
The comparison between Superman and Black Adam is fascinating because they represent two very different takes on the superhero genre. Superman is the ideal hero – noble, selfless, and almost god-like in his abilities, yet deeply human in his struggles. On the other hand, Black Adam is more of a force of nature, unpredictable and dangerous, yet still relatable because of his tragic backstory and desire for justice.
While Superman’s character arc focuses on his journey to accept his responsibilities and become the protector of Earth, Black Adam’s arc is about learning to control his rage and navigate the complexities of power. Both characters go through significant growth, but in opposite directions: Superman becomes more confident in his role as a hero, while Black Adam grapples with what it means to be a hero when vengeance drives him.
Storytelling and Plot Structure
Man of Steel: An Origin Story with Depth
Man of Steel takes the audience on a journey through Superman’s origins, starting with his birth on Krypton and his eventual arrival on Earth. The film spends a significant amount of time focusing on Clark Kent’s childhood and how he learns to harness his powers. The struggle between embracing his Kryptonian heritage and his earthly upbringing is central to the story.
The narrative is not simply about Superman’s battle with General Zod; it’s also about his internal struggle and the discovery of who he truly is. The destruction of Krypton, the loss of his home planet, and the eventual confrontation with Zod add emotional weight to the film. The film is structured with flashbacks that reveal important aspects of Superman’s past, allowing the audience to slowly peel back the layers of his character.
However, some critics felt that the pacing of the film was uneven, particularly during the large action sequences that may have overwhelmed the emotional depth of the story. Despite this, the film provides a fresh and grounded perspective on a familiar character.
Black Adam: A Story of Vengeance and Redemption
Black Adam takes a different approach to storytelling. Rather than being an origin story in the traditional sense, it focuses on Black Adam’s awakening in the modern world and his clash with the Justice Society. The film’s plot is built around the idea of power and how different characters interpret justice. Black Adam, as an anti-hero, views justice in a way that often involves destruction, while the JSA tries to impose a more traditional, morally upright approach.
The pacing of Black Adam is quick, with plenty of action sequences and fights, especially between Black Adam and the JSA. However, the story also provides moments for character development, particularly for Black Adam, who must confront his past and decide what kind of hero (or anti-hero) he wants to be. Unlike Superman, Black Adam’s character arc is less about embracing his identity and more about reconciling with the consequences of his actions.
While the plot can sometimes feel formulaic, the film’s darker tone and intense action sequences create an engaging experience. The introduction of the JSA and their dynamic with Black Adam also adds another layer to the narrative, offering a fresh take on superhero team-ups.
Visual Effects and Action Sequences
Man of Steel: Groundbreaking Action
The visual effects in Man of Steel are impressive, particularly in the large-scale battle sequences. The fight between Superman and General Zod in Metropolis is a highlight of the film, with the two Kryptonian-powered beings clashing in a cityscape filled with destruction. The film uses a mix of practical effects and CGI to create the illusion of superhuman strength and speed.
While the action scenes are intense and visually stunning, some critics have pointed out that the film can be overwhelming, with too much focus on destruction. However, for fans of superhero films, the large-scale battles offer an exhilarating experience that complements the character-driven narrative.
Black Adam: High-Octane Action and Spectacle
Black Adam delivers high-octane action that sets it apart from other superhero films. From the moment Black Adam awakens, the film delivers a series of explosive battles that showcase his raw power. His confrontations with the JSA, especially Hawkman and Dr. Fate, are filled with spectacle and intensity.
The film makes great use of CGI to showcase Black Adam’s powers, such as his ability to fly, his invulnerability, and his lightning-based attacks. The action is fast-paced and thrilling, with each character bringing something unique to the table. The film’s visual effects and choreography are top-notch, making it a visually satisfying experience for fans of action-packed superhero films.
Themes and Impact
Man of Steel: Heroism, Sacrifice, and Identity
The themes of Man of Steel are centered around heroism, sacrifice, and identity. The film explores what it means to be a hero in a world that doesn’t fully understand or accept you. Superman’s journey is one of self-discovery, as he learns to balance his alien heritage with his Earthly upbringing. The theme of sacrifice plays a significant role, especially in the final act, where Superman must make a difficult choice to protect humanity.
The film’s exploration of identity also resonates with many viewers, as it touches on universal themes of belonging, family, and the search for purpose. Superman’s struggle to define himself in the face of immense power and responsibility is one of the film’s strongest emotional arcs.
Black Adam: Power, Justice, and Redemption
Black Adam explores themes of power, justice, and redemption. The film asks important questions about what happens when a person with god-like powers seeks revenge, and whether redemption is possible for someone who has committed terrible acts in the past. Black Adam’s struggle is internal, as he battles with his desire for vengeance and the possibility of becoming a true hero.
While the film is more focused on action and spectacle, the themes of justice and redemption provide a deeper layer to the character of Black Adam. His journey is one of reconciling with his past and deciding whether he can change the course of his future.
Conclusion
So, which is better – Man of Steel or Black Adam? It ultimately depends on what you’re looking for in a superhero film. If you prefer a character-driven narrative with deep themes of identity, sacrifice, and heroism, then Man of Steel is likely the better choice. Its exploration of Superman’s origins and his internal conflict offers a fresh and grounded take on the character.
On the other hand, if you’re in the mood for a more action-packed, darker take on a superhero with a complex moral compass, then Black Adam may be more your style. The film’s fast-paced action, intense battles, and exploration of power and redemption provide an exciting experience that stands apart from more traditional superhero films.
Both films have their strengths, and neither can be definitively declared the “better” film. Instead, they offer different perspectives on what it means to be a hero, making them both worthwhile additions to the DC cinematic universe.
Related topics:
